Perth and Kinross Courts: Week’s Judgments Highlight Serious Offenses and Community Protection
The courts serving the Perth and Kinross region, along with wider Tayside, have recently concluded several significant cases, reinforcing the justice system’s commitment to community safety. Sentences handed down during the week included lengthy prison terms for sexual predators, highlighting the gravity of their crimes and the profound impact on victims. One such case saw **Caileon Ward**, a 26-year-old from Perthshire, incarcerated for 14 years following convictions at Glasgow’s High Court. Ward was found guilty of multiple violent and sexual offenses, including the rape of two women, which occurred between 2019 and 2023 in the Crieff area. Evidence presented indicated Ward’s callous disregard for his victims, with one woman recounting his chilling statement during a sexual assault: “At this point, I really do not f****** care.” This particular victim endured repeated abuse, including rape while she was asleep, and was later subjected to further sexual violence after explicitly refusing his advances. She was left deeply distressed and in considerable pain. In another horrifying incident, Ward terrorized this woman by brandishing a knife and demanding she undress. She eventually fled in fear, wearing only a T-shirt and underwear. A second victim also suffered a similar dehumanizing ordeal. On New Year’s Day 2023, Ward drove this victim erratically while under the influence of alcohol and drugs, at one point threatening to drive their vehicle over a bridge. The woman’s attempts to escape were thwarted as the car door was locked. He then menacingly ran a knife along her legs. Ward pleaded guilty to six charges, encompassing the repeated rapes of both women. Lord Scott, presiding over the case, mandated an additional four years of supervision for Ward upon his release. Police Inspector Stephen Gray commented, “Ward carried out these awful crimes over several years and he will now face the consequences of his actions in prison. My thoughts are with these women who showed immense strength in coming forward to report these crimes. I hope this sentencing will give them some comfort and help them move forward.” Betrayal of Trust in Perth City Centre In a deeply disturbing case that unfolded in the heart of Perth, a shop assistant, **Joshua Jerome**, was exposed for sexually assaulting a 62-year-old blind woman. The incident occurred at a Shamanic store in Perth city centre, where Jerome engaged in a depraved act behind the customer as she paid at the till. He also indecently exposed himself and groped the visually-impaired woman while she was browsing for jewellery. Shockingly, he even knelt to record a video up her skirt. Unbeknownst to him, the victim had secretly recorded his illicit behavior, leading to his apprehension. This egregious breach of trust in a local business sent shockwaves through the community, underscoring the vulnerability of individuals and the importance of vigilance. Extended Sentence for Dundee Teenager Attacker Further down the Tayside region, a sex offender named **Gavin Jackson**, 37, received an extended prison sentence for preying on two teenage girls in Dundee. Jackson, already on the sex offenders register for life, contested the charges at Dundee Sheriff Court but was ultimately found guilty by a jury. Sheriff Alastair Carmichael emphasized the gravity of the offenses, stating, “The jury convicted you of two serious offences. Both involved taking advantage of the complainers and pressuring unwanted sexual advances on them. You did this while you were in your 30s and these two women were then in their teens.” The judge highlighted the significant negative impact detailed in the victims’ statements. Jackson’s solicitor, Doug McConnell, offered little mitigation beyond a letter from the charity With You, detailing efforts to overcome substance addiction. The lawyer stated, “He appreciates the nature of the matter and would work with anybody willing to work with him. His position is the same as it was at the trial.” The court imposed an extended sentence of 30 months imprisonment, followed by 12 months of supervision in the community. Jackson remains subject to sex offender notification requirements for the remainder of his life, and the court issued seven-year non-harassment orders to protect his victims from any contact. Drug Dealers Jailed in Dundee In a separate incident focusing on drug-related crime, **James Ger** and **Dre Butler** were caught by police during a May 2024 raid at Hilltown Court in Dundee. The duo was observed attempting to discard cannabis out of a window as officers forced entry into their flat. Their capture resulted in significant prison sentences, reflecting the ongoing efforts by law enforcement to curb drug distribution within local communities. The pair were seen embracing in the dock as their sentences were handed down. Prison for Offender with Childhood Trauma Finally, a sex offender who abused a sleeping schoolgirl was also brought to justice. **Frank Stewart**, 23, was found guilty of three charges following a trial at Forfar Sheriff Court in August. Stewart carried the sleeping girl into another room and assaulted her in East Wemyss, Fife, in 2021. His DNA was found on her underwear, and traces of his saliva were on her jumpsuit. A year later in Forfar, Stewart abused a second girl, repeatedly groping and attempting to kiss her. He was also convicted of threatening and abusive behaviour, to which he responded, “I’m sorry, we’ve all done things we’re not proud of. I’m not a paedophile, I’m not a paedophile.” During sentencing, his solicitor, Billy Rennie, spoke of Stewart’s “very solitary existence” and early life trauma, including witnessing death at a young age. Mr. Rennie suggested Stewart would be “very vulnerable” in prison, stating, “A great fear is on him at the prospect of a prison sentence.” However, Sheriff Mark Thorley acknowledged the public risk, sentencing Stewart to two years in prison and placing him on the sex offenders register for a decade. He also issued 10-year non-harassment orders for both victims and a sexual harm prevention order, prohibiting Stewart from unsupervised contact with girls under 16. Stewart reacted with agitation as he was led from the dock following his sentencing, underscoring the severity of the court’s
Regional Care Sector Under Scrutiny: Key Findings Impacting Perth and Kinross Communities
Recent evaluations of care services across Tayside, Fife, and Stirling have brought to light a series of crucial findings, prompting local residents in Perth and Kinross to reflect on the standards of care in their own communities. These reports, issued by regulatory bodies, underscore the critical importance of safety, professional conduct, and compassionate practice within various care settings, from early learning environments to residential care and medical professions. The Care Inspectorate, the principal oversight body for care provision, meticulously assesses services like nurseries and care homes, rating their performance against established benchmarks. Similarly, the Scottish Social Services Council (SSSC) maintains professional standards for registered care workers, while the Medical Practitioners Tribunal Service (MPTS) oversees the conduct of doctors registered with the General Medical Council. The outcomes of their recent investigations serve as a vital reminder for families and service providers in areas such as Perth, Crieff, and Kinross, highlighting both areas of concern and the ongoing efforts to uphold quality care. Nursery Safety Concerns in Fife Highlight Need for Vigilance In a recent inspection, Cardenden Primary School Nursery in Fife received revised ratings following an improvement notice issued in June 2025. Initially, the nursery faced starkly low ratings across various aspects of its service, including care, play, learning, setting, leadership, and staff performance. The improvement notice specifically mandated changes to address the use of restrictive practices, ensuring that staff did not employ inappropriate physical intervention with children. During an October visit, inspectors acknowledged that the nursery had successfully implemented all required improvements concerning these restrictive practices. However, the Care Inspectorate’s report also indicated that two critical requirements pertaining to overall site safety and security remained unaddressed. Inspectors emphasized the need for nursery personnel to consistently and appropriately manage accidents and incidents, ensuring that families are promptly informed through accurate and timely record-keeping and reporting. Furthermore, the report advised the nursery’s provider to meticulously review its procedures for handling serious complaints and concerns, reiterating that these responses must consistently guarantee the safety and protection of children from potential harm. For Perthshire parents, these findings reinforce the continuous need for rigorous oversight and transparent communication in childcare facilities. Serious Professional Misconduct Cases Emerge in Regional Reports Beyond nursery settings, the reports also detailed significant instances of professional misconduct that have led to disciplinary actions against individuals working in care. In one notable case, a Stirlingshire nursery worker, Clair Frost, faced disciplinary action after making a false 999 call from a nursery near Loch Tay. This resulted in an extensive search operation, involving multiple emergency services, following her fabricated claim of an overturned kayak. Ms. Frost, 35, was convicted at Stirling Sheriff Court, leading to an SSSC probe. The council opted for a three-year warning on her registration, rather than a permanent removal, a decision that underscores the nuanced approach taken by regulatory bodies in balancing accountability with rehabilitation. Another incident involved Juliette Dilworth, a children’s worker in Fife employed by Crannoch Care in Lochgelly. She received a warning after being found to be significantly over the legal drink-driving limit while transporting a young person, identified as ‘AA’, in her car. Although off-duty, Ms. Dilworth had offered assistance to ‘AA’ who had missed a bus, acting in what was described as ‘good faith.’ However, a subsequent SSSC investigation concluded that her actions put the young person at risk and demonstrated ‘poor judgment.’ The SSSC also noted that she had provided ‘AA’ with her personal phone number, leading to several imposed conditions on her professional registration. These cases highlight the profound responsibility placed on care workers and the severe consequences of lapses in judgment. Care Home Worker’s Actions Cause Distress, Doctor Faces Tribunal The imperative for kindness, compassion, and respect in care settings was sharply underlined by the case of Morgan McNeilage-Melville, a senior care assistant at Richmond House care home in Crieff. Ms. McNeilage-Melville received a two-year warning on her social care registration after an SSSC report found she had caused emotional distress to vulnerable adults during incidents in February and October 2024. Her misconduct included making one resident cry and failing to adequately treat another’s wound following a fall. The SSSC emphasized that her actions impaired her fitness to practice, stressing the fundamental expectation that social care workers adhere to principles of kindness and respect. Such events in a nearby Perthshire town are a stark reminder to families in areas like Crieff and Auchterarder about the vulnerability of care home residents and the trust placed in their caregivers. In the medical field, Dr. William Gunn, 65, is set to face an MPTS tribunal in December after being convicted in January 2024 for covertly filming girls at a Starbucks in Kirkcaldy, Fife. The conviction included charges of covertly watching and staring at children, acting in a disorderly manner, taking photos and videos, attempting to film their bodies, and committing a breach of peace. This severe breach of professional conduct could result in Dr. Gunn being struck off the General Medical Council register. These varied cases collectively emphasize the ongoing vigilance required by regulatory bodies to maintain high standards of care and professional ethics across the Tayside, Fife, and Stirling regions, ensuring the safety and well-being of all individuals. Local authorities and care providers throughout Perth and Kinross continually review and reinforce their own guidelines, drawing lessons from such regional reports to bolster training and oversight. The commitment to safeguarding vulnerable individuals remains a top priority, with ongoing efforts to foster environments of trust, respect, and unparalleled care for all.
Perth’s Cakefest Delivers a Delicious Blend of Tradition and Talent
The heart of Perth was once again filled with the aroma of festive bakes and the joyous sounds of community celebration this past Sunday, as the much-loved Cakefest made its triumphant return. Synchronized with the city’s eagerly anticipated Christmas Lights Switch-On Weekend, the event transformed the Civic Hall at the Perth and Kinross Council headquarters on High Street into a bustling showcase of local culinary creativity. Bakers from across the region rose to the challenge, presenting their finest creations in a hotly contested competition. The event featured two distinct categories: the ‘Best Traditional Christmas Cake’, which celebrated classic recipes and time-honoured decorating techniques, and a ‘Freestyle’ section, encouraging participants to unleash their most innovative and imaginative designs. The sheer diversity on display, from intricate sugarcraft to daring flavour combinations, truly underscored the exceptional talent within the Perth and Kinross community. The competition offered tempting incentives for the region’s best bakers. Top honours in each category were rewarded with a generous £100 Perth Gift Card, an initiative that not only celebrated the winners but also encouraged vital local spending. Second and third-place entrants were also recognized for their remarkable efforts, each receiving a £50 gift card, further bolstering the local economy and fostering a spirit of friendly rivalry. The Historic Bakers’ Parade Marches On A particularly enchanting highlight of this year’s festivities was the vibrant revival of the ancient ‘Bakers’ Parade’. This centuries-old tradition, deeply rooted in the rich history of the ‘Fair City’, made a magnificent comeback, adding a unique historical flavour to the modern Christmas celebrations. Participants, many proudly carrying their meticulously crafted cakes and bakes, marched through the city centre in a colourful procession. Leading the spirited parade was the distinctive Absurdist Pipe Band, whose lively and unconventional melodies provided an unforgettable soundtrack as the procession wound its way along King Edward Street. The spectacle was further enhanced by graceful stilt walkers, whose towering presence added an element of whimsical wonder, captivating the crowds that lined the streets to cheer on the bakers and revel in the festive atmosphere. A Celebration of Local Skill and Community Spirit The dedication and artistry of the local bakers were evident in every single entry. The judging panel, which included esteemed local figure Provost Xander McDade, faced an exceptionally difficult task in evaluating the array of edible masterpieces. Each cake was a testament to countless hours of careful planning, precise execution, and a true passion for baking. The level of detail and originality in both the traditional and freestyle categories left a lasting impression on everyone present, from casual observers to seasoned culinary enthusiasts. Among the many talented individuals, Siobhan Campbell emerged as the victor in the fiercely competitive open category, a testament to her outstanding skill and creative vision. Her winning entry captivated the judges and stood out amidst a field of truly remarkable bakes, highlighting the high standards of local amateur baking. Beyond the excitement of the competition and the grandeur of the parade, Cakefest served as a powerful focal point for community engagement. It brought together families, friends, and neighbours, creating a warm, inclusive atmosphere that perfectly complemented the city’s Christmas Lights Switch-On. The event was a testament to Perth’s vibrant community spirit and its commitment to preserving and celebrating its unique traditions while embracing contemporary talent. The palpable sense of pride and camaraderie among attendees and participants alike underscored the enduring appeal of such local gatherings. Organisers and volunteers worked tirelessly to ensure the smooth running of all activities, from the intricate setup in the Civic Hall to the management of the street parade, demonstrating a collective dedication to making the event a resounding success. This collaborative effort not only provided a platform for local bakers but also strengthened the bonds within the community, reinforcing Perth’s identity as a city that values both its past and its present. The resounding success of Cakefest 2025 has firmly cemented its place as an essential fixture in Perth’s annual festive calendar. It beautifully combines the charm of age-old customs with the dynamism of modern creativity, ensuring that the ‘Fair City’ continues to offer enchanting and enriching experiences for both its residents and the many visitors drawn to its seasonal celebrations.
Perthshire Sheltered Housing Residents Terrorised by Knifeman in Disturbing Rampage
A recent incident in a tranquil sheltered housing complex in Stanley, Perthshire, has left residents deeply shaken, after a man wielding knives launched a terrifying spree of aggression and intimidation. John Hayton, 53, unleashed a wave of fear, forcing one elderly individual to flee their home and a female neighbour to take refuge in her bathroom, fearing for her life. The distressing events unfolded on the evening of July 9, beginning when Hayton approached a neighbour’s door, shouting aggressively and repeatedly banging. When the occupant opened, Hayton immediately accused him, yelling: “You know what you’ve done. You’ve killed my mum.” Without invitation, he then violently pushed his way into the property, launching a barrage of kicks and punches at the man. In a desperate attempt to de-escalate the situation, the resident managed to push Hayton back out of his home. However, the attacker quickly re-entered and locked the door, trapping the resident outside his own property. Distressed, the man called out to a nearby neighbour, urging her to contact the authorities for help. Moments later, Hayton burst back out of the property, resuming his assault on the first victim, all while continuing his agitated tirade about his mother. The situation escalated dramatically as Hayton brandished two kitchen knives, which he had reportedly taken from the victim’s kitchen. He pursued the terrified man, shouting deeply disturbing threats, including: “You paedo, you paedo, I’m going to f***ing kill.” The victim, described as utterly petrified, managed to escape the chase and sought refuge in another resident’s home. A Horrifying Encounter The ordeal continued as Hayton then entered the home of the woman who was on the phone to the police. He confronted her, pointing a large kitchen knife with a black handle directly towards her throat. Although the blade did not make physical contact, it was held at arm’s length, causing the woman immense terror. She recounted being “terrified and scared for her life” during the harrowing encounter. During this chilling confrontation, Hayton made a series of irrational demands. He repeatedly asked the woman about the whereabouts of his mother, calling her by different names. When she attempted to clarify her identity, he vehemently demanded proof. Even after she presented him with a letter bearing her name and address, he dismissed it, refusing to believe her. His behaviour grew increasingly erratic as he then demanded to know “where the stairs were that went under the house.” The terrified woman, struggling to comprehend his agitated state, tried to explain that no such stairs existed in her home. This rational response only intensified Hayton’s rage. He began shouting furiously, waving the knife menacingly, and threatening to stab her if she was lying. In a desperate bid to survive the ordeal, she pointed towards the back of the house, indicating that the stairs might be found there. As soon as Hayton exited the property in search of these non-existent stairs, the woman seized the opportunity to lock her door immediately. However, her relief was short-lived. Hayton returned moments later, banging and kicking violently, attempting to regain entry. The traumatised woman, now fearing for her life even more acutely, barricaded herself in her bathroom. It remained unclear whether Hayton ultimately managed to force his way back inside through an open window. Police Intervention and Legal Consequences The volatile situation prompted a rapid response from armed police officers, who swiftly descended upon the cul-de-sac in Stanley, a typically serene Perthshire village where such disturbing events are uncommon. Confronting Hayton, who initially concealed his hands behind his back, an officer deployed a taser, ‘red-dotting’ him before he complied with instructions to drop the knives and get to the ground, where he was subsequently restrained. However, Hayton’s aggressive behaviour persisted. While being transported to Dundee Police Headquarters in a police van, he made further threats, telling an officer he would slit their throat. His erratic state meant that officers were initially unable to formally charge him. Appearing before Perth Sheriff Court, John Hayton pleaded guilty to multiple serious charges, including assault, threatening and abusive behaviour, and illegal possession of knives. His defence lawyer, David Holmes, informed the court that his client claimed to have no memory of the incidents. Holmes noted that Hayton had a lengthy criminal record, predominantly for acquisitive crimes, and had even been found in Aberdeen the week prior with no recollection of how he got there. Despite this claim, medical professionals who assessed Hayton did not support a Section 51a application, a legal defence asserting that an accused person was not responsible for their conduct due to a mental disorder. This means the court will proceed with sentencing based on his guilty pleas. Sheriff Simon Collins KC underscored the gravity of the offences, stating clearly that Hayton should anticipate a “significant custodial sentence.” Hayton has been held in remand since his arrest, awaiting the final judgment. This incident serves as a stark reminder of the importance of community safety and the vulnerability of residents in sheltered housing, even in quieter corners of Perth and Kinross. The swift response by emergency services undoubtedly prevented further harm and brought a measure of security back to a deeply distressed neighbourhood.
Significant Traffic Flow Enhancements Unveiled at Key Dundee Roundabout Affecting Perthshire Commutes
Commuters and travelers from across Perth and Kinross who regularly navigate the major A90 corridor will be interested in the recently completed modifications at the well-known Swallow Roundabout in Dundee. This critical junction, a gateway to the city often used by residents of Perth, Kinross, and the surrounding regions for daily commutes and onward journeys, has undergone its latest phase of improvements aimed at bolstering safety and streamlining vehicle movement. The alterations specifically address long-standing concerns regarding driver confusion and congestion, particularly following the introduction of traffic lights earlier this year. The initial comprehensive project to reconfigure the roundabout, necessitated by increased traffic volumes anticipated from the nearby Western Gateway housing development at Dykes of Gray, concluded in March. For the first time, this major interchange saw the installation of traffic signals, a change that, while intended to improve flow, inadvertently led to new challenges. A subsequent safety review highlighted certain aspects of the new layout as ‘confusing,’ prompting calls for further adjustments to enhance clarity for motorists. In response to these findings, remedial work commenced recently. This period, unfortunately, introduced further complexities for drivers as the main traffic signals were temporarily deactivated, causing fresh instances of driver uncertainty and near misses. However, this follow-up project has now reached its conclusion, with all traffic lights fully reactivated and the new road markings firmly in place. While the developers, Springfield Properties, have remained tight-lipped on the granular details of the ‘technical amends,’ citing proprietary reasons, a closer inspection of the changes offers valuable insights for our local drivers. Key Modifications for Perthshire Drivers One of the most impactful changes for Perth and Kinross residents travelling towards Dundee involves the approach from the Perth direction, particularly for those intending to turn right onto Riverside Drive. Previously, the road markings on this dual carriageway approach presented a confusing scenario: the outside lane appeared to cater to both straight-on traffic heading towards the Kingsway (A90 North) and those turning right onto Riverside Drive (A85). However, once on the roundabout, vehicles in this outside lane were then compelled to take the Riverside Drive exit. This often left drivers feeling ‘trapped’ or forced into an unintended lane, a situation frequently highlighted in public feedback and safety audits. Under the new configuration, this ambiguity has been substantially clarified. Motorists can now confidently remain in the outside lane when approaching the roundabout if their destination is northwards onto the Kingsway (A90). A significant innovation is the gradual emergence of a third ‘breakout’ lane on the outer periphery of the approach, delineated by a broken white line. This dedicated lane is specifically for traffic intending to turn right onto the A85 Riverside Drive, effectively resolving the prior ‘trapping’ issue and providing a much clearer path for all drivers. Enhanced Roundabout Lane Guidance Beyond the approach, subtle yet crucial adjustments have been implemented within the roundabout itself. A recurring issue identified in the initial setup was the uncertainty experienced by drivers entering the roundabout from the Perth direction and aiming for Riverside Drive. This often led to hesitation about which of the two subsequent lanes to utilize at the next set of signals, contributing to hazardous situations and close calls. With the latest modifications, traffic entering the roundabout with the intention of exiting onto Riverside Drive is now intuitively guided into the correct lane for a seamless exit, mitigating previous points of conflict. This improvement is further aided by the strategic introduction of another ‘breakout lane’ on the inner side of the roundabout, designed for vehicles turning right from the Dykes of Gray area towards Perth. Additionally, new road markings on the northbound lanes provide unambiguous instructions, clearly designating the two left lanes for the A90 continuation and the right-hand lane for the A85 exit. Impact on Perth & Kinross Journeys For drivers from Perth, Crieff, or other parts of Kinross-shire, these adjustments promise a more predictable and potentially safer passage through what has been a notoriously complex junction. While the core element of the roundabout – the traffic lights – remains a point of contention for some, often contributing to tailbacks, the enhanced lane guidance is a welcome development. Anecdotal evidence suggests that while delays may still occur, especially during peak times, the overall clarity and reduced potential for sudden lane changes offer a marked improvement in driver confidence. For instance, a recent journey by one of our reporters during a weekday morning observed that while the presence of traffic lights could still lead to queues, the new markings made navigating the junction significantly more straightforward. Even with a brief standstill behind a vehicle turning off towards Dykes of Gray, the underlying impression was one of improved safety. The lights, love them or loathe them, are now a permanent fixture, but the emphasis on clear and intuitive lane management is expected to make journeys less stressful and more secure for the countless Perthshire residents relying on this vital transport artery.
Pitlochry Woman Jailed for Draining Over £117k from Elderly Mother’s Account
A Perthshire woman has been imprisoned for systematically stealing a significant sum of money, amounting to over £117,000, from her own mother, who was in her nineties and resided in Pitlochry. The shocking case, heard at Forfar Sheriff Court, highlights a profound betrayal of trust within a family setting. Catriona MacAulay was found guilty of a calculated scheme that saw her illicitly withdraw and divert £117,747.32 from her mother, Phyllis Stewart, over a six-year period. The theft commenced in May 2013 and continued until May 2019, during which time MacAulay exploited her access to her mother’s finances, including bank cards and chequebooks, to make cash withdrawals, settle personal bills, and transfer funds to herself and other family members. A Mother’s Trust Betrayed in Pitlochry The victim, Mrs. Phyllis Stewart, lived on West Moulin Road in Pitlochry, a tranquil town nestled in the heart of Perth and Kinross. Tragically, Mrs. Stewart passed away in 2020 at the age of 98, never fully recovering from the financial depredations. The period of theft coincided with MacAulay moving in with her elderly mother, ostensibly to provide care and companionship, a detail that further underscores the severity of the breach of trust. The scale of the theft is particularly striking, considering the vulnerability of Mrs. Stewart due to her advanced age. Cases of financial abuse against the elderly are deeply concerning, especially when perpetrated by those closest to them, and this incident will undoubtedly resonate with residents across Perth and Kinross, reminding them of the importance of vigilance and safeguarding within families. MacAulay’s Defence and the Court’s Decision During her trial, MacAulay, now residing in Marshall Mews, Perth, attempted to justify her actions. The 63-year-old, who previously held positions at both the Bank of Scotland and RBS, claimed that her mother was a generous individual who willingly provided financial assistance to her and her daughters. She recounted that her father had managed the family’s finances until his death in 2013, after which she took over. MacAulay detailed various expenditures, suggesting that some funds were used to support one of her daughters on a six-month study trip to Malaysia. Other outlays included tickets for rugby matches at Murrayfield, general household provisions, such as vacuum cleaners, and decorative archways for the ‘huge showpiece’ garden at her mother’s Pitlochry home. She also mentioned significant four-figure cheques written to her daughters, one of which was supposedly for a laptop, and payments for vehicle tax. She asserted that her mother saw her as a full-time carer and wished to compensate her for her services and for maintaining the garden. However, the jury at Forfar Sheriff Court ultimately rejected MacAulay’s defence, finding her explanations insufficient to account for the substantial sums that had disappeared from her mother’s accounts. The court heard how MacAulay had moved from her Dunblane home to live with her mother in February 2018, citing her mother’s ‘loneliness,’ and also worked part-time with the Clan Donnachaidh Society during this period. Sheriff Mark Thorley presided over the sentencing, which had been deferred to allow for a social work report. Defence advocate Colin Neilson argued for a non-custodial sentence, highlighting MacAulay’s minimal ‘criminogenic needs’ and her otherwise productive life with two adult daughters. He acknowledged the ‘significant and adverse aspect’ of the six-year duration of the offence on the mother-daughter relationship and pointed out that the offences were now ‘of some age.’ Justice Served for a ‘Gross Breach of Trust’ Despite the defence’s pleas, Sheriff Thorley concluded that the nature and scale of the crime left him with no alternative but to impose a custodial sentence. He emphasized the ‘incredibly large sum of money’ involved and the ‘extensive period of time’ over which the theft occurred. Crucially, the Sheriff described MacAulay’s actions as a ‘gross breach of trust,’ a factor that weighed heavily in his decision. MacAulay was subsequently sentenced to 18 months in prison. The court also inquired about the possibility of compensation for Mrs. Stewart’s estate, but it was confirmed that no lump sum was available. This outcome underscores the devastating financial impact on the victim’s estate, a stark reminder of the long-lasting consequences of such crimes. This case serves as a somber warning about financial elder abuse and the profound damage it can inflict, not only on the immediate victim but also on wider family relationships and community trust within areas like Pitlochry and the broader Perth and Kinross region.
Perth Man Convicted for Role in Racially Aggravated Knuckleduster Attack
A recent trial at Perth Sheriff Court has seen local resident Darren McMillan found guilty of his involvement in a racially charged assault that took place in a city centre alleyway. The incident, which occurred on April 24 of last year, involved a violent altercation where an asylum seeker was attacked with a knuckleduster. McMillan, aged 23 and residing on Kestrel Way, was apprehended attempting to escape the scene in a taxi. The court heard distressing testimony regarding the victim, 25-year-old Kru Bantan, who was discovered bleeding heavily from a head wound following the attack in an alley situated just off South Methven Street – a bustling thoroughfare in Perth known for its shops and eateries. During the three-day proceedings, jurors were presented with evidence detailing how Mr. Bantan was subjected to a brutal beating by another individual, a friend of McMillan’s who has since passed away. This individual was confirmed to be wearing a knuckleduster during the assault. While allegations that McMillan himself brandished a large kitchen knife at the scene were not substantiated by the evidence, he was ultimately convicted of acting in concert with his accomplice in the violent act. A key aspect of the prosecution’s case highlighted the clear racial prejudice behind the attack. Witnesses recounted that the primary attacker made overtly racist remarks to Mr. Bantan, stating something to the effect of: ‘No, because you’re black and I don’t want you here,’ after being asked for a cigarette. This prejudicial motivation was a significant factor in the jury’s verdict. The Aftermath and Evidence Uncovered The severity of the assault was evident from the victim’s condition, with Mr. Bantan reportedly ‘soaked in blood’ and suffering a cut to the back of his head. The swift response of an off-duty police officer, who intervened and summoned assistance, was crucial in disrupting the attack and ensuring its aftermath was investigated. One of the key witnesses, 25-year-old Habib Drammen, who knew Mr. Bantan as a neighbour from the Queens Hotel – an establishment on Leonard Street that has housed asylum seekers for several years and has recently been the site of various community discussions and protests – provided his account to the court. Mr. Drammen described seeing Mr. Bantan being ‘grabbed by two men’ and being punched repeatedly by the shorter assailant using a knuckleduster. He also testified to seeing McMillan with what he believed was a knife, which deterred his direct intervention, though this specific charge against McMillan was ultimately not proven. Mr. Drammen recounted shouting at the attackers to ‘Leave him alone, because he’s my friend’ and even falling down while being pursued by McMillan. His testimony refuted the defence’s claim that he and Mr. Bantan had attempted to rob the two men. Drug Discovery and Court Proceedings In a significant turn of events following the assault, McMillan’s attempt to flee in a taxi from Mill Street was short-lived. Police intercepted the vehicle and arrested him. During a subsequent search at Dundee police headquarters, officers made a substantial discovery. From inside McMillan’s underwear, a black box containing 23 individually wrapped plastic bags of crack cocaine was recovered. The street value of these packages was estimated to be around £1,100, adding a serious drug offence to McMillan’s legal woes, to which he had already pleaded guilty prior to the assault trial. Despite McMillan’s defence, which asserted that he merely witnessed a scuffle where Mr. Bantan allegedly attempted to rob his friend, the jury weighed all the evidence. After more than four hours of deliberation, they found him guilty of working in concert with the other man to assault Mr. Bantan, repeatedly punching and pushing him on the head and body with knuckledusters, causing injury. The jury also formally recognised the offence as aggravated by prejudice, explicitly referencing the Hate Crime and Public Order (Scotland) Act 2021. Although the charge concerning the possession of a knife was not proven, the conviction for the racially aggravated assault stands as a stark reminder of the importance of community safety and respect for all individuals residing in Perth. Sheriff William Wood has deferred sentencing for McMillan to allow for background reports to be prepared, and McMillan’s bail has been continued pending these reports. This case underscores the ongoing efforts within Perth and Kinross to address and condemn acts of prejudice and violence, ensuring that justice is pursued in incidents that threaten the fabric of the community.
Crieff Community Garden in Mourning After ‘Wilful’ Fire Destroys Vital Equipment
A much-loved green space in the picturesque Perthshire town of Crieff has been left reeling after a destructive fire, believed to have been deliberately started, ravaged its main storage shed. The incident, which took place late on Friday, November 21, 2025, has sparked deep sadness and anger among the dedicated volunteers and local residents who cherish the Crieff Community Garden. Emergency services were alerted to the blaze at the garden, located off Monteath Street, just before 10pm. The fire swiftly engulfed the shed, reducing its entire contents to unsalvageable debris. The loss is extensive, encompassing a wide array of essential gardening tools and machinery, including several lawnmowers, a wood chipper, leaf blowers, strimmers, and litter pickers – all indispensable for the garden’s daily maintenance and public engagement programmes. Furthermore, stocks of paint and signage, numerous chairs used for community gatherings, and even water butts, planters, and a communal bench positioned adjacent to the shed, were all consumed by the flames. The monetary value of the destroyed property is estimated to exceed £2,000, representing a substantial blow to this volunteer-driven local initiative. The circumstances surrounding the fire point strongly towards a deliberate act. A local resident living near the garden provided a concerning eyewitness account, observing a group of youths in the immediate vicinity as fire crews were arriving on scene. This neighbour also distinctly recalled hearing a loud ‘bang,’ which is thought to have been the sound of petrol, likely from one of the stored lawnmowers, combusting within the inferno. These observations have profoundly influenced the police investigation, which is now treating the fire as wilful. For the unwavering team of volunteers at the Crieff Community Garden, this act of destruction transcends mere material loss; it represents a profound emotional and communal wound. Catriona Smith, a prominent figure and dedicated volunteer in the garden project, candidly articulated the deep-seated sorrow felt by many. She expressed profound heartbreak, voicing a fervent hope that the Crieff community gardeners would receive an outpouring of local support to surmount this immense hurdle, steadfastly refusing to let the perpetrators achieve a victory over their collective spirit. A Community Hub Facing Repeated Adversity The Crieff Community Garden is far more than just a patch of cultivated land; it is a vibrant testament to community resilience and collaboration. Its transformation began in March 2020, blossoming into a vital outdoor project during the unprecedented period of lockdown. What started as a shared vision to clear neglected ground and cultivate new life has evolved into an invaluable community resource, enriching the lives of countless individuals and families across Crieff and the surrounding Perth and Kinross area. Over the years, the garden has flourished into a diverse and engaging green space. It boasts dedicated zones for children, featuring a popular mud kitchen, numerous raised planting beds for community members to grow their own produce, and a functional polycarbonate greenhouse that extends growing seasons. The garden actively hosts a range of community events, from organised litter picks that foster civic pride to educational sessions where local nurseries and school pupils enthusiastically participate in planting activities and learn about nurturing vegetables, connecting with nature in a tangible way. However, this latest act of devastation is not an isolated incident. Catriona Smith revealed that the garden has been a target of recurrent vandalism, recalling a particularly “heavy onslaught of vandalism” that occurred in October 2023. This pattern of malicious damage has taken a severe toll on the morale of the dedicated volunteers. Catriona openly shared the emotional burden, stating that the very place which once filled her with immense joy and pride now, sadly, triggers feelings that compel her to actively avoid it, due to the persistent negative impact on her mental well-being. She further highlighted the frustration inherent in continuously repairing and replacing damaged property. Each piece of discarded litter or act of destruction, she explained, feels like a painful blow to her and every individual who has freely contributed their time and effort to cultivate this cherished community greenspace. A significant concern for the volunteers is the financial implication: a substantial portion of the garden’s funding is provided by Perth and Kinross Council. Catriona pointed out the regrettable reality that local taxpayers’ money, specifically allocated to support community initiatives, is repeatedly being diverted to address senseless acts of destruction. She articulated a strong sense of indignation that individuals within the community would engage in such destructive behaviour without facing appropriate accountability. Her poignant words, “It sickens me that members of our community would do this, and never seem to be held to account. Certainly no one reimburses our community group everytime they smash a bench or set fire to a lawnmower,” underscore the deep-seated frustration felt by those who tirelessly work for the betterment of their local environment. Official Investigations Underway The Scottish Fire and Rescue Service confirmed their response to the incident, with a spokesperson stating: “We were mobilised at 9.58pm on Friday. It was a fire in the open that one pump was deployed to extinguish. The stop message came in at 10.45pm. Police were informed about the incident.” Police Scotland has since launched a full investigation into the matter. A Police Scotland spokesperson confirmed: “Around 10.35pm on Friday, 21 November, 2025, officers received a report of a fire on Monteath Street, Crieff. The fire is being treated as wilful, and enquiries are ongoing. Please quote incident number 3827 of Friday, 21 November 2025.” The classification of the fire as “wilful” by authorities unequivocally indicates a deliberate act, intensifying the local community’s concern and widespread condemnation of the incident. This disheartening setback for the Crieff Community Garden serves as a powerful reminder of the challenges faced by volunteer-led projects across Perth and Kinross. These invaluable community assets, often sustained by the sheer dedication and unwavering generosity of local residents, thrive on a foundation of respect and collective support. While the rebuilding process for the Crieff Community Garden will undoubtedly demand considerable effort and resources, the resilient spirit and
Perth and Kinross Courts Tackle Wide Range of Offences: From Covert Surveillance to Domestic Abuse
The courts across Perth and Kinross have been actively addressing a diverse array of criminal cases this week, underscoring the relentless pursuit of justice within our communities. Proceedings have brought significant outcomes in cases ranging from severe domestic abuse and an update on a high-profile murder trial to instances of calculated fraud and deeply personal privacy invasions. Each case highlights the judiciary’s commitment to upholding the law and protecting residents throughout the region. A Perth-based electrician, Kevin Watt, received a stern sentence at Perth Sheriff Court for a terrifying and sustained campaign of abuse against his former partner. Harrowing details emerged of how Watt lured the woman to his Victoria Street flat under the guise of reconciliation, only to trap her and subject her to a horrific ordeal. During her captivity, she was physically assaulted, including being headbutted and bitten on the face, and was denied sleep, prevented from escaping to her children. This disturbing pattern was not new, as Watt had a history of making extreme threats, including one to ‘chop off her head’. Represented by his defence agent, the behaviour was acknowledged as ‘repugnant’. Sheriff Simon Collins KC imposed a comprehensive sentence: 300 hours of unpaid community work, a six-month restriction of liberty order requiring him to stay indoors between 9 pm and 6 am, and two years of stringent supervision. Furthermore, Watt has been mandated to attend the Caledonian Programme, a specialist initiative for domestic offenders, and is subject to a five-year non-harassment order, prohibiting any contact with his former partner. High-Profile Murder Trial Progresses In a significant development, a trial date has been formally set for David Campbell, a former head gamekeeper accused of the shotgun murder of 65-year-old Brian Low. The tragic incident, which shocked the serene community near Aberfeldy, occurred in February 2024. Campbell, now 76, appeared for his final procedural hearing, where the High Court scheduled the highly anticipated trial to begin on February 2, 2026. This lengthy timeframe reflects the intricate nature of such serious cases and the extensive preparation required to ensure all legal aspects are thoroughly examined. Separately, a rapist, Dylan Cameron, was handed a substantial seven-and-a-half-year prison sentence following a horrific five-year ordeal inflicted upon a woman, primarily in Dunfermline. Cameron, now 28, attempted to deflect responsibility by claiming he was ‘confused about sexual boundaries’ and that his age influenced his actions. However, Lord Stuart, presiding at the High Court in Glasgow, vehemently rejected these claims. The judge dismissed them as untruthful attempts to reduce culpability and deemed them ‘insulting to the vast majority of young people,’ emphasizing that his actions were ‘obvious to any right-minded member of society’ as harmful. Cameron had been convicted of rape, physical assault, and a course of abusive behaviour. His history of previous convictions and multiple breaches of community payback orders further exacerbated his sentence. Upon release, he will undergo an additional three years of supervision, remain on the sex offenders register indefinitely, and is permanently banned from contact with his victim. Elaborate Cons and Covert Surveillance Exposed Two brazen individuals, Benjamin Payne and Alexander Rush, are now behind bars after orchestrating a ‘cruel con’ in Stirlingshire. Posing as police officers, they terrified an elderly couple, with the victim, in her eighties, recounting how she and her now-deceased husband were coerced into handing over tens of thousands of pounds worth of precious diamonds, sapphires, and emeralds. This calculated act of deception preyed on the vulnerability of senior citizens, extending the impact of such crimes across our broader regional communities. In another case involving covert actions, Gary Archibald, a self-employed father from Forfar, faced justice at Forfar Sheriff Court for stalking his former partner. Archibald admitted to secretly placing a tracking device in the front passenger-side wheel arch of his ‘school sweetheart’s’ vehicle, monitoring her movements for 17 days. While his solicitor described this as a ‘moment of madness’ stemming from family concerns, and noted Archibald had no prior offences, Sheriff Mark Thorley firmly declared the use of a tracking device ‘utterly unacceptable’. Archibald was fined £1,000, plus a £40 victim surcharge, to be paid within 28 days, and was issued a strict 12-month non-harassment order, prohibiting any contact with the victim. Duncan McPhee, a serial thief from Bridge of Earn, also appeared in court for preying on a 94-year-old Fife pensioner. Posing as a window cleaner, McPhee distracted the elderly householder, entered his home, and stole his wallet and bank cards from a money box. He then used one of the stolen cards to withdraw £650. This despicable act, heard at Perth Sheriff Court, highlights the need for vigilance against those who exploit trust, particularly within our older population. Spycam Restriction Lifted Amid Family Ties Andrew Thomas, a 50-year-old former offshore worker with a history of voyeurism, successfully applied to Perth Sheriff Court to have some of his post-sentencing restrictions relaxed. Thomas had previously admitted to an egregious invasion of privacy: he hid an iPhone in a flower vase at the foot of a 65-year-old woman’s bed, recording over 40 hours of intimate footage, including her undressing. The victim discovered the Velcro-fixed camera while simply arranging an artificial bouquet. This was a repeat offence for Thomas, who had a prior conviction for secretly filming a female colleague on an oil rig. His initial sentence in April included a six-month restriction of liberty order, 300 hours of unpaid work, and five years on the sex offenders register, along with strict conditions that banned him from approaching his victim or entering her home village near Pitlochry. However, Thomas successfully argued for the village ban to be lifted due to his family residing there. Following police confirmation that the victim no longer lived in the area and with no objection from Fiscal Depute Lissie Cooke, Sheriff Peter Anderson agreed to remove this specific restriction.
Perth’s Tabla Indian Restaurant Extends Warmth and Generosity with Free Christmas Day Meals
In a heartening display of community spirit, a cherished Indian eatery located on Perth’s bustling South Street is once again preparing to offer complimentary festive meals this Christmas Day. Praveen and Swarna Kumar, the dedicated proprietors of Tabla Indian Restaurant, are continuing their now three-year-old tradition of providing hot, freshly prepared dinners to individuals and families in need, as well as to the tireless emergency services personnel across Perth and Kinross. The roots of this remarkable initiative run deep, stemming from Praveen’s childhood experiences in a small village in India. There, it was customary to invite the less fortunate into one’s home for a Christmas dinner, fostering a profound sense of shared community. Transplanting this deeply personal value to his adopted home in Perth, Praveen and Swarna have chosen to dedicate a day that could otherwise be highly profitable to a cause close to their hearts: ensuring that no one in their local community goes without a nourishing meal during the festive period. On Christmas Day, Tabla Indian Restaurant will temporarily close its doors to regular diners, transforming its kitchens into a hub of festive production. The talented culinary team will be busily preparing a special menu of starters and main courses, all destined for those who might otherwise face a solitary or challenging festive season. These carefully prepared meals will be both delivered to various locations and available for direct collection from the restaurant itself, ensuring maximum accessibility for anyone in need of a warm plate and a gesture of kindness. Last year, the program saw an incredible outpouring of support, reaching numerous local beneficiaries. Meals were gratefully received by staff at Perth Royal Infirmary, the local fire service, and police officers working hard to keep the community safe. Beyond the frontline services, the Kumars extended their generosity to seven local charity houses, including vital organisations such as the Salvation Army and Shelter Scotland, making a tangible difference to many vulnerable residents throughout Perth and its surrounding areas. This year, the team is already taking pre-orders from several charity houses and departments within facilities like Murray Royal Hospital, demonstrating the sustained need and appreciation for their efforts. The success of this annual endeavour relies not only on the Kumars’ dedication but also on the remarkable spirit of local volunteers. Last year, numerous individuals from Perth and Kinross generously offered their time and vehicles to assist with deliveries, ensuring that hundreds of meals reached their intended recipients across the region. This collective effort truly embodies the compassionate and supportive nature that defines our community, transforming a simple act of giving into a widespread network of care. The core philosophy driving this heartwarming tradition is straightforward: to guarantee that everyone has at least one proper, comforting meal on Christmas Day. In a world where festive cheer can sometimes highlight feelings of isolation or hardship for others, initiatives like this serve as a vital lifeline and a beacon of hope. It underscores the profound impact that local businesses and their families can have when they actively participate in strengthening the social fabric of their town. Tabla Indian Restaurant will be open for meal collection between 11 am and 2 pm on Christmas Day, welcoming anyone who wishes to partake in the festive fare or simply enjoy a moment of shared humanity. Requests for these complimentary meals can be made easily through Tabla’s various social media platforms. It’s also worth noting that this generous offering is part of a broader trend of local kindness, with another coffee shop in Perth also planning to serve free Christmas Day meals, showcasing the collective heart of Perth and Kinross during the holiday season.