Major Perthshire Route Closed at Glendevon Following Evening Collision
A significant disruption has occurred on a key Perthshire arterial route, as the A823 at Glendevon was closed following a two-vehicle collision on Thursday evening. The incident, reported to authorities shortly after 7 PM, prompted an immediate response from emergency services, leading to the full closure of this vital thoroughfare. The A823, a picturesque yet often winding road that connects various communities within Perth and Kinross, became impassable as a result of the crash. This closure impacts local commuters, residents, and anyone planning journeys through the Glendevon area, which serves as a crucial link for traffic heading towards or from regions like Muckhart, Yetts of Muckhart, and beyond into Fife or Stirling. Emergency Response and Road Advisory Upon receiving reports of the collision, emergency crews were swiftly dispatched to the scene. Their immediate priority was to secure the area, manage the situation at the crash site, and ensure public safety. The nature of the incident necessitated a complete blockage of the road, leading to a direct and unequivocal warning from law enforcement. A spokesperson for Police Scotland confirmed the situation, stating: “The A823 is closed at Glendevon following a two-car crash reported to police at 7.05pm on Thursday. Road users are advised to avoid the area.” This official guidance underscores the need for motorists to plan alternative routes and exercise heightened caution if travelling in the vicinity. Impact on Local Travel and Community The closure of the A823 at Glendevon is more than just a traffic inconvenience; it directly affects daily routines and accessibility for many within the Perth and Kinross community. Residents of surrounding hamlets and villages, who rely on this route for work, school, and essential services, are facing extended travel times and diversions. Evening travel, already challenged by reduced visibility, becomes particularly complicated when primary routes are affected in this manner. While the full extent of the incident and any potential injuries are not yet known, the presence of emergency services indicates a serious situation. Authorities are focused on their ongoing efforts at the scene, working diligently to clear the roadway and restore normal traffic flow as quickly and safely as possible. Motorists are encouraged to remain patient and allow extra time for their journeys if their routes are impacted by this incident. This event serves as a timely reminder of the importance of vigilance and careful driving, particularly on rural roads that can present unique challenges. Conditions can change rapidly, and adhering to police advice to avoid affected areas is paramount for everyone’s safety. Local residents are advised to stay informed through official channels for updates regarding the A823’s reopening and any continuing traffic management measures. Further details will be released by the relevant authorities as the situation develops and their on-site operations conclude. The community’s understanding and cooperation are vital during such unforeseen road disruptions.
Hotel Tragedy Highlights Urgent Need for Safety Upgrades in Perthshire
A recent inquiry into a fatal accident at a Pitlochry hotel has brought critical safety concerns to the forefront, prompting calls for immediate improvements across the Perth and Kinross hospitality sector. The incident, resulting in the tragic loss of a local resident, underscored significant maintenance failures that contributed directly to the devastating outcome. The deceased, a long-time resident of the region, was a valued member of the community. His untimely death has shaken the local area, leading to widespread grief and prompting discussions about the responsibility of accommodation providers to ensure the safety and well-being of their guests. The details revealed during the inquiry were deeply concerning, highlighting the critical need for change. Faulty Systems and Inadequate Response The inquiry detailed numerous reports of issues with the hotel’s water systems. Guests had previously expressed concerns about inconsistent shower temperatures. These reports, which were not adequately logged or addressed, revealed a disturbing pattern of negligence. The faulty thermostatic mixing valve, responsible for regulating water temperature, played a crucial role in the accident. The hotel’s failure to promptly and professionally resolve these issues proved to be catastrophic. Further compounding the tragedy was the design of the bathroom itself. The outward-opening door, secured by an interior bolt without an exterior emergency release, proved a significant obstacle to rescue efforts, delaying crucial assistance. This highlights the importance of designing accommodations with safety as a top priority, including readily-accessible emergency release mechanisms on all doors, especially in bathrooms. Recommendations for Improvement The inquiry made several key recommendations. Regular inspections and maintenance of all water-heating systems are paramount, along with a robust system for documenting and addressing all guest complaints. The findings emphasize the urgent need for proactive maintenance schedules and the implementation of effective safety protocols. The tragic event serves as a stark reminder of the potential consequences of neglecting these crucial steps. Beyond the specific hotel, the inquiry’s findings have broader implications for the entire Perthshire tourism industry. Local councils and regulatory bodies now face the urgent task of ensuring all establishments within their jurisdiction meet the highest safety standards. The community expects a rapid and decisive response to prevent similar tragedies from occurring in the future. The impact of this tragedy extends far beyond the immediate family. The loss has resonated throughout the community, underscoring the need for collective action. Local businesses, community organizations, and residents are all urged to support initiatives focused on enhancing safety in Perth and Kinross accommodations. The memory of the deceased should inspire a renewed commitment to safety. The recommendations provided by the inquiry must be taken seriously and implemented swiftly and thoroughly. This will not only protect future guests but also serve as a testament to the community’s collective responsibility to ensure that such a tragedy is never repeated. The picturesque landscapes and charming towns of Perth and Kinross attract visitors from around the world. Maintaining the highest standards of safety is crucial for preserving the region’s reputation for hospitality and welcoming travelers. The steps taken in response to this incident will demonstrate the region’s determination to safeguard its reputation as a safe and enjoyable destination. The inquiry’s findings have sparked a much-needed conversation about the importance of maintaining safe and well-maintained accommodation across the region. The local community’s response will undoubtedly shape the future of hospitality safety standards in Perth and Kinross, ensuring a commitment to the well-being of both residents and visitors. Going forward, proactive measures should be emphasized to create a culture of safety and prevention within the hospitality industry. The incident highlights the importance of collaboration between local businesses, regulatory bodies, and the community to prevent future tragedies. The legacy of this tragic event should be a renewed focus on safety standards, ensuring that Perthshire remains a welcoming and secure destination for all.
Perth Killer’s Parole Bid Rejected Again, Sparking Renewed Calls for Justice Reform
A convicted killer from Perth, Robbie Smullen, has once again been denied parole, five years into a nine-year sentence for the fatal stabbing of a young man in the Fair City. This latest decision by The Parole Board for Scotland marks the second time Smullen’s application for early release has been refused, reigniting discussions around the current parole system and its impact on grieving families across Perthshire. The ruling was delivered on Thursday, a significant development for the victim’s family who have tirelessly advocated for justice. Smullen was incarcerated following his conviction for the culpable homicide of 22-year-old Barry Dixon. The tragic incident occurred on June 4, 2019, at a flat located in Wallace Court, a residential area within Perth. The court determined that Smullen was responsible for Dixon’s death by knifing him. This recent rejection follows a previous denial last October, meaning that Smullen’s pursuit of freedom has been a recurring concern for the victim’s relatives. Barry Dixon’s aunt, Jade Taylor, has confirmed that the Parole Board has scheduled Smullen’s next review for July 2026. This extended period between hearings aligns more closely with Ms. Taylor’s earlier request for at least a year’s间隔 between reviews, a plea born from the emotional toll of frequent proceedings. Under existing Scots Law, individuals serving sentences like Smullen’s are automatically considered for parole annually once they reach the halfway point of their term. This legislative framework, while intended to facilitate rehabilitation and reintegration, has inadvertently placed an immense and recurring burden on victims’ families, forcing them to relive their trauma with each successive hearing. Expressing profound relief at the board’s decision, Ms. Taylor articulated the family’s ongoing struggle. “We feel massively relieved Smullen will remain in prison,” she stated. She emphasized the critical need for systemic changes, reiterating the family’s unwavering support for the impactful ‘A Voice for Victims’ campaign. This initiative champions a comprehensive overhaul of the parole system, aiming to prevent the ongoing suffering inflicted upon those left behind by violent crime. The core tenet of the ‘A Voice for Victims’ campaign, which has garnered considerable support across the Perth and Kinross community, is the cessation of automatic annual parole considerations for violent offenders once they reach the halfway mark of their sentences. Instead, the campaign advocates for a system that prioritises the well-being of victims, ensuring enhanced communication and greater transparency throughout the parole process. Ms. Taylor passionately questioned the rationale behind a system that mandates repeated parole hearings for violent criminals, arguing that they should simply serve their full sentence, thereby affording victims a much-needed period of peace and closure. The momentum for parole reform appears to be building at a national level. A public consultation on the matter is anticipated to commence in the coming month, an announcement made earlier this year by Justice Secretary Angela Constance. Furthermore, the Victims, Witnesses, and Justice Reform (Scotland) Bill, currently progressing through the Scottish Parliament, is expected to incorporate significant reforms pertaining to parole regulations. These legislative efforts offer a glimmer of hope for families like the Dixons, who yearn for a more victim-centric approach to justice. The continuous efforts of Perthshire families, advocating for a more compassionate and transparent parole system, underscore a wider demand for judicial processes that truly prioritize the long-term emotional and psychological recovery of victims and their loved ones. The unwavering determination of local advocates like Jade Taylor ensures that the voices of those affected by serious crime continue to be heard in the halls of power, pushing for changes that promise greater peace and less recurrent trauma for communities throughout Scotland.
Perthshire Fuel Fraudster Ordered to Pay Compensation After Elaborate A90 Scheme
A military veteran involved in a significant fuel fraud operation at a service station near Invergowrie, within the Perth and Kinross area, has been ordered by a local court to make restitution for the substantial losses incurred. Brendan Scanlan, aged 31, admitted his central role in orchestrating a scheme that allowed other motorists to obtain vehicle fuel without payment at the Bullionfield premises located directly off the A90. The intricate deception, which involved Scanlan illicitly using his employer’s corporate payment card to cover the cost of fuel for acquaintances who were simultaneously filling their tanks at adjacent pumps, persisted for a period of six weeks. The fraudulent activity ceased only when his company uncovered the irregularities and promptly alerted law enforcement. Investigations revealed that Scanlan had engaged in a total of 26 illicit transactions, accumulating a debt of £8,254 worth of fuel. During the court proceedings at Perth Sheriff Court, details emerged regarding Scanlan’s personal circumstances that led to his involvement in the scheme. His defence explained that he had anticipated receiving a substantial compensation payout from the Ministry of Defence. This expected sum was intended to address hearing damage he sustained during his military service, and Scanlan had harboured intentions of using it to fully reimburse the affected fuel retailer. However, this expectation was not met, as the final settlement he received was considerably less than initially advised by his legal representatives. While he was told he could expect £58,000, the actual amount was £11,000, which, after various deductions, left him with approximately £8,800. Solicitor Mark Robbins, representing Scanlan, highlighted his client’s existing financial difficulties, including significant drug-related debts that his father had previously settled. He also noted Scanlan’s current efforts to address outstanding obligations to HMRC. The court was informed that Scanlan had lost his lucrative employment following the exposure of the fraud but had since secured a factory position, demonstrating his commitment to re-establishing a stable work life. Presiding over the case, Sheriff William Wood, delivering the sentence at Perth Sheriff Court, characterised Scanlan’s actions as “quite a cynical crime.” He acknowledged the impact this had on Scanlan’s former employment but expressed satisfaction at his return to work. The Sheriff imposed a community payback order, requiring Scanlan to undertake 140 hours of unpaid work within the local community. Additionally, he was placed under supervision for a period of one year. A confiscation order was issued for the full amount of £8,524, with an initial payment of £500 required immediately. Concluding his remarks, Sheriff Wood conveyed a poignant message to Scanlan, expressing his hope that, for his own dignity, he would manage to repay the entire sum. “I know that as a former soldier that will be important to you,” the Sheriff stated, underscoring the intrinsic value of honour and accountability that often resonates within the military community. This case serves as a stern reminder of the consequences of fraudulent activities within our local communities, reinforcing the commitment of the justice system in Perth and Kinross to hold individuals accountable for their actions and to ensure victims are compensated where possible. The ruling from Perth Sheriff Court sends a clear message that such deceptions will be met with firm legal repercussions, while also acknowledging the individual’s journey towards rehabilitation and personal responsibility.
A9 Near Miss Leaves Campervan Driver Injured; Police Seek Hit-and-Run Driver
A serious incident unfolded on the A9 near Perth and Kinross, leaving a campervan driver hospitalized and prompting a police investigation into a suspected hit-and-run. The collision, which occurred on Wednesday evening, involved a white Volkswagen campervan and another vehicle, described as being gold or silver in color. The incident took place between Calvine and Dalnamein, a stretch of road familiar to many Perthshire residents who regularly travel between Perth and the Highlands. Emergency services responded swiftly, transporting the 36-year-old female campervan driver to Ninewells Hospital in Dundee for treatment. However, the other vehicle involved in the collision didn’t remain at the scene. Police are currently appealing to the public for information to identify the driver of the second car. This is particularly important, given the serious injuries sustained by the campervan driver. The impact of such incidents underscores the importance of road safety for all drivers in Perth and Kinross, and the community is urged to come forward with any information that could be helpful to the investigation. Road Closure and Investigation The incident necessitated a temporary road closure on the A9 to allow emergency services and police officers to conduct a thorough investigation at the scene. This disruption likely impacted the travel plans of many commuters and tourists passing through this stretch of the A9, a vital transport route connecting Perthshire to wider Scotland. The road closure lasted approximately an hour and a half, reopening around 7:30 pm, after the incident had been fully assessed and the area secured. Such incidents highlight the importance of clear communication during emergencies and the efficiency of our local emergency services in responding to and managing the aftermath of significant events. The police’s timely response ensured the safety of those involved and the swift reopening of the A9 minimized wider disruption to road traffic. The quick re-opening was due to efficient planning and coordination between the emergency services and local council. Community Appeal for Information Police Scotland are keen to trace the driver of the gold or silver car that left the scene. They’re calling on anyone who was in the vicinity of the A9 between Calvine and Dalnamein around 6:10 pm on Wednesday to come forward. Witness statements, even seemingly insignificant details, can help piece together the events leading up to and following the crash. The police have also issued a call for dash-cam footage from motorists who were in the area at the time of the incident. Dash cams are increasingly common in vehicles across Perth and Kinross, and the footage can often provide crucial evidence in investigations. The appeal for information underlines the importance of community participation in maintaining public safety within Perth and Kinross. Police Scotland regularly rely on the support of local residents to solve crimes and bring perpetrators to justice. This sense of community spirit and shared responsibility is vital to ensuring a safe and secure environment for all residents and visitors. A Reminder of Road Safety This incident serves as a stark reminder of the importance of responsible driving. The A9, while a scenic route, can be challenging in certain stretches. Maintaining safe driving speeds, paying close attention to road conditions, and being vigilant to other road users, are crucial for preventing accidents. Local driving schools and initiatives frequently emphasize the importance of driver safety education and the impact responsible driving has on local communities. The impact on individuals and families affected by accidents is often devastating. The incident also underscores the gravity of leaving the scene of an accident. Failing to stop and render assistance is not only a serious offence, but it can also hinder investigations and prevent emergency services from providing timely medical care to those injured. The local justice system addresses the legal consequences of such actions firmly to maintain accountability and deter dangerous driving practices. By doing this Perth and Kinross and wider Scotland can promote safety and order. Police are urging anyone with information regarding this incident to contact them on 101, quoting reference number 3034 of July 30th, 2025. The prompt and effective response by Police Scotland and other emergency services will help ensure that the A9 near Perth and Kinross remains a safe route for drivers and the surrounding area is kept safe.
A9 Highland Perthshire Crash: Campervan Driver Hospitalised as Second Vehicle Flees Scene
A significant road traffic incident unfolded on the A9 within Highland Perthshire earlier this week, leading to the hospitalisation of a female driver and triggering an immediate police investigation. The collision, which occurred on Wednesday evening, involved a campervan and another vehicle, leaving a stretch of this critical arterial route temporarily disrupted and highlighting ongoing concerns for road safety in the region. Emergency services, including police and ambulance crews, were rapidly deployed to the scene located between the picturesque locales of Calvine and Dalnamein. This particular section of the A9, renowned for its breathtaking scenery but also for its challenging and often winding routes through the heart of Highland Perthshire, saw its normal flow of traffic halted. Initial reports from traffic monitoring services indicated that one of the vehicles, identified as a white Volkswagen campervan, had overturned during the impact, underscoring the considerable force involved in the collision. The swift response was crucial given the often-remote nature of accidents in this part of Perth and Kinross. The 36-year-old woman who was at the wheel of the overturned campervan sustained injuries in the incident. She received immediate medical attention at the roadside before being promptly transported from the rural Highland Perthshire location to Ninewells Hospital in Dundee. This journey to a major regional medical facility underscores the serious nature of her injuries and the integrated network of emergency care that serves Perthshire’s communities, ensuring that even remote incidents can access high-level trauma support, reflecting the strategic importance of such services for a vast geographical area. A troubling aspect of the incident is the fact that the driver of the second vehicle involved in the crash failed to remain at the scene. This vehicle, described by witnesses as being either gold or silver in colour, departed prior to the arrival of police responders. Incidents where drivers flee the scene of an accident are always treated with utmost gravity by law enforcement. Such actions not only compound the distress for other parties involved but also significantly hinder immediate casualty care and obstruct the crucial process of understanding the full circumstances of the event. Abandoning a crash site places an additional burden on emergency services and can prolong disruptions on vital transport links essential for local residents and travellers, particularly on a major route like the A9, which connects communities from Perth through to the Highlands. Authorities from the Perth roads policing unit swiftly initiated a comprehensive inquiry into the incident. Road closures were implemented for a period to allow investigators to meticulously examine the scene, gather evidence, and ensure the safety of other road users. The A9, while a lifeblood for many communities in Perth and Kinross, connecting them to the wider Scottish infrastructure, also presents unique challenges for road safety and policing due to its length, varying conditions, and diverse terrain, from bustling urban stretches near Perth to quieter, more isolated sections further north. This particular incident serves as a stark reminder of the unpredictable nature of road travel and the paramount importance of responsible conduct by all who use our roads. In their ongoing efforts to gather all pertinent information, law enforcement officials are actively reaching out to members of the public. They are particularly keen to hear from anyone who may have been travelling on the A9 between Calvine and Dalnamein on Wednesday evening, specifically around 6:10 PM. Eyewitness accounts, no matter how minor, or any form of digital recording, such as dash cam footage from vehicles traversing the area at that time, could prove invaluable to the investigation. Community cooperation is often a pivotal factor in resolving such complex cases, helping to bring clarity to incidents and ensure accountability for all parties involved, fostering a safer environment for everyone in Perthshire. The investigation continues its diligent work to uncover the complete picture surrounding this serious crash. The primary objective remains determining the precise circumstances that led to the collision and identifying the driver who left the scene, ensuring that all aspects of road safety and legal responsibility are upheld on Perthshire’s vital road network. This incident underscores the continuous efforts by police and road safety partnerships across Perth and Kinross to promote safer driving practices and respond effectively to all road incidents, aiming to protect everyone who uses the region’s extensive transport infrastructure and maintain the safety of routes like the A9, which is crucial for local commerce, tourism, and daily commutes.
Perth Green Energy Executive Avoids Prison Term for £70,000 Embezzlement
A prominent figure in Perth’s green energy sector has been spared a custodial sentence after admitting to the embezzlement of a substantial £70,000 from his own company. Scott Bathgate, 45, faced judgment at Perth Sheriff Court, where concerns over his personal vulnerabilities within a prison environment played a significant role in the court’s decision. The court heard how Bathgate systematically diverted company funds over a five-year period. These misappropriated sums, which he channeled into an account he crudely labeled a ‘booze fund,’ were used to finance a lavish lifestyle, including extravagant holidays, numerous restaurant outings, and subscriptions to dating websites. This pattern of financial misconduct represents a profound breach of trust, particularly within a small to medium-sized enterprise where financial integrity is paramount. The Breach of Trust at My Eco Solutions My Eco Solutions, the Perth-based firm targeted by Bathgate’s actions, was co-founded by him and his business partner, Douglas Hamilton, in 2011. Initially established with a vision to contribute to sustainable energy solutions, the company placed considerable trust in Bathgate, entrusting him with a company bank card and a credit card for business-related emergencies. As the business grew and its operations expanded, Bathgate was given full and unchallenged responsibility for its accounts and overall administration. However, cracks began to appear in the company’s financial management under Bathgate’s purview. It became increasingly clear that he was struggling to maintain accurate bookkeeping. This disarray led to the company incurring numerous fines for late payments, a fact that his business partner, Mr. Hamilton, remained entirely unaware of, highlighting the deceptive nature of Bathgate’s control over the finances. Uncovering the Deception The extent of Bathgate’s embezzlement began to unravel in 2016 when the company was advised to operate under a different trading name, prompting a review of its financial structures. The arrival of a new office manager later that year proved to be a pivotal moment. Bathgate’s reluctance to provide his log-in details to the new manager immediately raised suspicions, triggering an internal investigation that would ultimately expose the full scale of his financial malfeasance. By January 2017, the new office manager successfully gained full access to the business accounts. What she discovered was a clear and systematic pattern of unauthorized transfers of funds directly into Scott Bathgate’s personal account. The revelation that he had used the explicit and brazen name ‘Booze Fund’ for this illicit account underscored the casual disregard with which he treated the company’s money. Douglas Hamilton, upon being informed of these transactions, confirmed their illegitimacy and expressed his dismay, having believed that the original Barclays bank account used for these transactions had long since been closed. Bathgate subsequently admitted guilt to the charge of embezzling £70,000 by transferring funds from the company’s business account to his personal account for his own personal expenditures and bill payments. Sentencing and Judicial Rationale Returning to Perth Sheriff Court for his sentencing, Bathgate arrived with a holdall, a physical symbol of his readiness for a potential prison term. However, his solicitor, Lynsey Barber, presented a pre-sentencing report emphasizing her client’s health issues, arguing that he would be ‘extremely vulnerable in a custodial setting.’ She acknowledged the severity of his actions, stating that Bathgate was fully aware of the significant repayment he would need to make and recognized the profound negative impact his ‘conscious decision’ had on the company and its employees. Sheriff William Wood, in delivering his judgment, acknowledged the gravity of the case. He stated, ‘This case has caused me a great deal of concern. You appear before the court having admitted embezzling £70,000 from the company which trusted you and which you were involved with from its outset.’ The Sheriff further highlighted the tangible cost of Bathgate’s actions: ‘That cash could have improved the financial viability of the company and the lives of the people who worked for it.’ Despite the seriousness, Sheriff Wood ultimately opted against immediate imprisonment. He explained, ‘This sort of deceit over an extended period of time would result in custody being the uppermost in the court’s mind.’ However, he added, ‘I am persuaded that given some time that has elapsed since this dishonesty ended, and taking into account your own vulnerabilities and health issues, custody is not the only way this matter can be dealt with.’ Instead, Bathgate, whose addresses were noted as formerly in Blackford and currently in Scone, was ordered to complete 300 hours of unpaid work within the community. Given Bathgate’s current unemployed status and low income, Sheriff Wood clarified that he could not impose a compensation order at this time. Nevertheless, he expressed a clear expectation: ‘It is hoped that you will find a way to pay back to the company the money you embezzled from them.’ This case serves as a stark reminder of the consequences of financial dishonesty and the complexities involved in judicial sentencing, particularly when personal circumstances intersect with the severity of the crime.
Perth Killer’s Parole Board Hearing Renews Calls for Justice System Reform
A critical parole board hearing is underway today for Robbie Smullen, the individual convicted of culpable homicide in connection with the tragic death of 22-year-old Barry Dixon. Smullen’s appearance before the board marks his second attempt at securing release, a development closely watched by the Perth community, still grappling with the profound impact of the 2019 incident. The devastating event occurred on June 4, 2019, when Barry Dixon was fatally stabbed at a flat in Wallace Court, a location that remains etched in the collective memory of Perth residents. Smullen was subsequently handed a nine-year prison sentence for his role in the young man’s death. His latest parole hearing comes just months after his initial bid for freedom was rejected last October, approximately halfway through his custodial term. Adding a layer of concern and controversy to the process, Smullen was granted temporary release just weeks after his parole was denied in November. This decision by the Scottish Prison Service (SPS) has raised questions among those affected by the crime, highlighting perceived inconsistencies within the system. Family’s Enduring Struggle and Campaign for Change For Barry Dixon’s aunt, Jade Taylor, the ongoing parole proceedings represent a painful and frustrating ordeal. She has been a tireless advocate, campaigning vigorously to ensure Smullen remains incarcerated. Her determination stems not only from personal grief but also from a broader desire for systemic improvements that would better serve victims and their families. The process of notification itself has proven to be a significant challenge for Ms. Taylor. She initially received a mere two weeks’ notice for Smullen’s parole date, which was originally set for July 2. However, this date was abruptly postponed, and it was only through her proactive contact with the Victim Notification Scheme (VNS) on the very eve of the rescheduled hearing that she learned of the change. This eleventh-hour communication lapse underscores the very issues that victim advocates seek to address. Expressing the deep frustration felt by many, Ms. Taylor powerfully articulated her anguish: “When do victims get a break? The Scottish Government need to make urgent changes to the parole system for violent killers because victims deserve so much better than this.” Her words resonate strongly with Perth and Kinross families who have experienced the profound trauma of violent crime and the subsequent complexities of the justice system. A Community’s Voice for Victims Barry’s family, alongside countless others in Perth and across Scotland, are staunch supporters of The Courier’s ‘A Voice for Victims’ campaign. This vital initiative champions comprehensive reforms to Scotland’s parole system. Key demands of the campaign include a fundamental re-evaluation of the current practice wherein violent criminals are automatically considered for parole upon reaching the halfway point of their sentences. Furthermore, the campaign calls for enhanced communication channels between the parole board and victims’ families, ensuring they are kept informed with clarity and compassion. Greater transparency surrounding parole decisions is also a central tenour, aiming to demystify a process that can often feel opaque and arbitrary to those directly impacted. In response to growing public demand and sustained advocacy, Justice Secretary Angela Constance announced earlier this year that a consultation on parole reform is anticipated to commence next month. A Scottish Government spokesperson confirmed that this consultation would explicitly “include consideration of points raised by victims of their experiences of the parole system.” This commitment signals a potential turning point, offering a glimmer of hope that the voices of individuals like Jade Taylor will finally be heard and acted upon. Further reforms aimed at bolstering the rights and experiences of victims within the justice framework are also under active consideration as part of the upcoming Victims, Witnesses, and Justice Reform (Scotland) Bill. As the Perth community and advocates nationwide watch closely, there is a collective hope that these legislative and procedural changes will bring about a more just, transparent, and empathetic parole system for all.
Tragic Pensioner Death: Perthshire Hotel Slammed Over ‘Avoidable’ Safety Failures
A recent Fatal Accident Inquiry has cast a stark light on significant safety lapses at a well-known hotel in Pitlochry, Perthshire, following the tragic death of a 75-year-old man in December 2019. The inquiry concluded that the death of Wallace Hunter, who became trapped and fatally scalded in a bathroom, was entirely preventable, leading to strong criticism from his grieving family and their legal representatives. Mr. Hunter, a resident of Eaglesham in East Renfrewshire, was a guest at the Pitlochry Hydro when the devastating incident occurred. At approximately 8:30 in the morning, he found himself unable to exit the bath. His calls for help were reportedly hampered by a bathroom door that opened outwards and was secured by a bolt, trapping him inside. Despite desperate attempts to free him, including efforts by hotel staff and eventually firefighters, Mr. Hunter remained in the bath. When emergency services finally gained entry, the tap was still running, and the water temperature was dangerously high, confirming the horrific circumstances of his passing. Inquiry Highlights Critical Lapses Sheriff John MacRitchie, presiding over the inquiry at Alloa Sheriff Court, delivered a clear and unequivocal judgment: Mr. Hunter’s death could, and should, have been avoided. The Sheriff highlighted several critical failings within the hotel’s operational procedures. Specifically, he pointed out the absence of regular, annual checks on water taps, a deficiency made more egregious by previous complaints concerning water temperature. Furthermore, the inquiry determined that the bathroom door’s design, which prevented it from being opened from the outside in an emergency, was a contributing factor to the tragedy. It was noted that the mixer tap in question was over three decades old and suffered from a ‘very sensitive’ temperature control, issues that an investigation by the Health and Safety Executive (HSE) later corroborated. Thankfully, the hotel, now under new ownership since its closure in 2020 and reopening in 2021, has since addressed these serious safety concerns. For Wallace Hunter’s family, the details uncovered during the inquiry have been a source of immense pain and indignation. His son, Keir, and daughter, Kimberley, expressed the profound difficulty of reading the sheriff’s judgment, describing it as depicting their father’s ‘excruciating and drawn out final moments.’ They stated directly that the judgment ‘shines a light on the fact that his death could and would have been avoided had the hotel used qualified maintenance staff and had the most basic of maintenance regimes in place for its hot water supply.’ Their statement went on to reveal that ‘The fault which caused our father’s death had been complained about by many previous guests and was well know to the the hotel management,’ and that ‘They ignored these warnings. We are frankly appalled that this hotel was allowed to open its doors to the public in 21st century Scotland.’ Calls for Accountability and Broader Industry Change Glen Millar, a partner at Thompsons Solicitors Scotland, who represented the Hunter family, echoed the family’s sentiments and provided a broader context for the systemic failures. He remarked that he struggles to recall another case where a fatality resulted from ‘such a litany of avoidable failures.’ Mr. Millar emphasized that the tragic events that befell Mr. Hunter could easily have occurred to ‘any one of the many elderly guests who stayed at the hotel in the years leading up to this tragedy.’ He viewed the sheriff’s judgment as a significant ‘vindication’ for a family that has shown remarkable determination and dignity, not only in enduring the loss of their loved one but also in confronting what he termed the ‘abject failure to acknowledge culpability by both hotel and insurers.’ The legal team now hopes that the inquiry’s findings will expedite the resolution of a separate civil action that the family has initiated at the Court of Session in Edinburgh. The inquiry heard compelling evidence, including that Mr. Hunter was conscious for a significant period after he realized he could not turn off the tap, prior to succumbing to the scalding water. While Sheriff MacRitchie acknowledged that it was ‘not possible to definitively state whether earlier rescue would have resulted in Mr Hunter’s survival,’ he underscored the ‘real and lively possibility that had Mrs Hunter or others been able to enter the bathroom and assist Mr Hunter from the bath and/ or turn off the tap at an earlier time Mr Hunter may have survived.’ This poignant observation reinforces the critical importance of swift emergency access and proper maintenance protocols in all public accommodation settings. The Sheriff’s concluding remarks served as a powerful call to action, urging that ‘The lessons learned from the death of Mr Hunter should now be utilised to prevent such events from happening again elsewhere, and the findings of this inquiry should alert all hotels or other establishments to recognise the real potential for such a fatal scalding to take place, and to analyse relative risk accordingly.’ This case serves as a stark reminder to businesses across Perth and Kinross, and indeed Scotland, of the profound responsibility they bear for the safety and well-being of their guests, ensuring that such a tragedy is never repeated within the hospitality sector.
Kinross Man Suffers Severe Chainsaw Injuries in Violent Home Invasion Over Tractor Dispute
A recent high-profile case at the High Court has brought a shocking act of violence in the quiet Perth and Kinross village of Kinross into sharp focus. Donald Sandilands, also known as Donna Sandilands, has admitted to a brutal assault on an 80-year-old local resident, Alexander McTavish. The incident, stemming from a financial disagreement over a tractor sale, escalated into a terrifying ordeal involving a chainsaw, leaving the elderly victim with severe and permanent injuries. The distressing events unfolded on February 9 of this year, turning a routine evening into a nightmare for Mr. McTavish and his partner. The gravity of the assault, its unexpected nature in a peaceful community, and the extreme methods employed by the assailant have sent a clear message of concern throughout Kinross and the wider Perth and Kinross area. The Origins of a Violent Dispute The roots of this harrowing confrontation lie in a transaction that occurred in November of the previous year. Mr. McTavish had sold a tractor for £3,500 to Ewan Sandilands, the assailant’s father. Subsequent to the sale, certain issues with the tractor’s performance or condition came to light, prompting ongoing discussions between Mr. McTavish and Ewan Sandilands about a potential refund or replacement. While these negotiations were seemingly confined to the original parties, Donald Sandilands, despite having no direct involvement in the purchase, became deeply aggravated by his father’s unresolved grievance. This growing frustration on Donald Sandilands’ part rapidly spiralled into explicit threats. Evidence presented during the court proceedings, including alarming text messages exchanged between Donald Sandilands and his father on the day of the attack, revealed a clear intent to inflict harm. In one particularly chilling communication, Donald Sandilands ominously declared: “I’m going to kill him tonight.” This chilling vow foreshadowed the horrific home invasion that was soon to follow. Terrifying Home Invasion and Brutal Attack Mr. McTavish and his partner were enjoying a quiet evening at their Kinross residence when their peace was shattered. The sound of violent banging outside signalled the arrival of Sandilands, who deliberately drove a vehicle through their garden gate. What immediately followed was a scene of pure menace: Sandilands emerged, wielding a fully operational chainsaw, its engine roaring with a terrifying intensity. The sight of the whirring blades and the assailant’s aggressive demeanor filled the air with palpable dread as he advanced toward Mr. McTavish. In a desperate attempt to avert disaster, Mr. McTavish retreated into his conservatory, pleading with Sandilands, “Donald, what are you doing?” and urging him to switch off the dangerous tool to allow for a calm discussion. However, rationality had clearly abandoned Sandilands, who responded with a torrent of shouts and expletives. His chilling demand was simple and stark: “Get my father’s money or I will kill you.” The terrifying standoff continued, dominated by the relentless whine of the chainsaw. As Mr. McTavish tried to close the glass doors of the conservatory for safety, Sandilands, with violent resolve, forced the chainsaw through a gap, shattering the glass. The whirling chain made brutal contact with Mr. McTavish, striking his left hip and, more critically, his left hand. In a desperate, self-preserving action, the elderly man attempted to push the lethal weapon away, but the chainsaw struck his hand once more, causing catastrophic damage. The victim later described his fingers as being “hanging on by the bone”—a testament to the horrific impact of the assault. Swift Police Response and Lasting Injuries Severely wounded and in immense distress, Mr. McTavish retreated further into his living room, with Sandilands still pursuing him. Meanwhile, showing remarkable composure under pressure, Mr. McTavish’s partner had barricaded herself in a bathroom and successfully placed an emergency 999 call. Emerging later, she witnessed Sandilands further damaging their home, striking the television with the chainsaw. It was at this critical moment, as Mr. McTavish fled the house with his attacker still in pursuit, that armed police units, having received the urgent call, arrived on Kinross High Street. Officers immediately confronted Sandilands, ordering him to drop the dangerous chainsaw. Faced with the direct threat of a taser, the assailant finally complied. Upon his apprehension, Sandilands made defensive and contradictory statements to the police, claiming, “If I wanted to kill him, I would’ve killed him,” and attempting to shift blame: “I didn’t try to kill him. He is making it up. He cut himself on the chainsaw. He tried to run and grab it.” Mr. McTavish, however, was in dire need of medical attention and was swiftly transported to Ninewells Hospital in Dundee. There, he underwent extensive surgery on his left hand to repair severe tendon damage. The physical toll of the attack is profound and permanent: Mr. McTavish has tragically lost the functional use of two fingers, a life-altering impairment. He also received treatment for an injury to his left side. Legal Proceedings and Community Impact The High Court was informed of Donald Sandilands’ background, noting his previous occupation as a mechanic and a past incident where he sustained brain damage after being struck by a tree. Sandilands ultimately admitted to a charge of assault to severe injury, permanent impairment, and disfigurement, acknowledging that his actions had placed the victim’s life in danger. Lord Ericht has deferred sentencing to a later date, pending the preparation of a comprehensive background report. Sandilands remains remanded in custody, with the sentencing hearing scheduled for August 27 at the High Court in Dundee. This shocking act of violence in Kinross has undoubtedly caused distress and concern among local residents, highlighting vulnerabilities even in seemingly peaceful rural settings. The long-term impact on the victim, his family, and the broader community of Perth and Kinross underscores the devastating consequences when personal disputes escalate to such extreme levels. As the legal process continues, the community awaits a resolution that brings justice for the victim and reinforces the commitment to safety in Perth and Kinross.